Home News Top MLB The Show 25 Diamond Dynasty Cards and Lineups Revealed for March 2025

Top MLB The Show 25 Diamond Dynasty Cards and Lineups Revealed for March 2025

by Jacob Jul 01,2025

Here is the SEO-optimized and content-polished version of your article, preserving all original structure, formatting, and placeholder elements as requested:


With the launch of *MLB The Show 25*, Diamond Dynasty makes a triumphant return—offering players the chance to collect powerful cards of today’s top MLB stars and legendary icons. Whether you're building a competitive squad or just diving into the grind, knowing which cards stand out can give you a strong edge in-game. Below, we’ve compiled the most effective Diamond Dynasty cards and optimal lineups for March 2025 to help you dominate on the diamond.

Best Diamond Dynasty Cards in MLB The Show 25 Right Now

While the cards available at launch may not end up being the final powerhouses of the meta, they are still highly valuable and form a solid foundation for your squad. Here are some of the top-performing cards currently making waves in MLB The Show 25.

Team Affinity James Wood

James Wood as part of an article about best Diamond Dynasty cards in MLB The Show 25.

The Washington Nationals' rising outfield star, James Wood, is obtainable through the Team Affinity program. While unlocking him takes effort, his well-rounded offensive profile makes it worthwhile. He offers consistent contact against both lefties and righties, complemented by solid power for a corner outfielder. Expect him to thrive in the heart of your lineup.

Pipeline Program Walker Jenkins

Walker Jenkins as part of an article about best Diamond Dynasty cards in MLB The Show 25.

Although Walker Jenkins plays center field in real life, his elite batting stats make him a flexible fit anywhere in your lineup. His balanced mix of contact and power ensures he contributes every time he steps up to bat. While his speed isn’t blazing fast, he can turn singles into doubles with ease.

20th Anniversary Clayton Kershaw

Clayton Kershaw as part of an article about best Diamond Dynasty cards in MLB The Show 25.

A longtime powerhouse in MLB The Show, Clayton Kershaw returns in MLB The Show 25 as part of the 20th Anniversary series. His pitching card features a dominant arsenal highlighted by his iconic 12-6 curveball. With a reasonable market price, even budget-conscious players can afford to add this ace to their rotation.

Live Series Emmanuel Clase

Emmanuel Clase as part of an article about best Diamond Dynasty cards in MLB The Show 25.

When it comes to late-game dominance, Emmanuel Clase stands out among relief pitchers. Though his pitch selection isn't flashy, his high-velocity fastball and game-breaking slider make him a shutdown closer. Slotting him into the CP role gives your team a reliable finisher in tight matches.

Related: Best Pitching Settings for MLB The Show 25

Best March 2025 MLB The Show 25 Diamond Dynasty Lineup

Confidence in your lineup is key when stepping into Ranked play. This curated squad balances performance and accessibility, focusing on cards that are realistically obtainable without requiring ultra-rare Live Series versions of top-tier players like Aaron Judge or Shohei Ohtani.

  • 20th Anniversary Elly De La Cruz (SS)
  • Pipeline Program Walker Jenkins (LF)
  • Prospect Pipeline Jordan Lawlar (3B)
  • Team Affinity James Wood (RF)
  • Spring Breakout Max Clark (CF)
  • 20th Anniversary David Wright (DH)
  • Team Affinity Craig Biggio (C)
  • Spring Breakout JJ Wetherholt (2B)
  • Prospect Pipeline Nick Kurtz (1B)
  • 20th Anniversary Clayton Kershaw (SP)
  • Live Series Felix Bautista (RP)
  • Live Series Emmanuel Clase (CP)

This setup delivers a balanced offensive attack with enough defensive flexibility and pitching depth to handle any opponent. Each player brings something unique to the table, whether it's raw power, contact consistency, or dominant mound presence.

And there you have it—the top MLB The Show 25 Diamond Dynasty cards and recommended lineups for March 2025. If you’re looking to improve your squad further, check out our guide on whether to go to college or go pro in Road to the Show.

MLB The Show 25 is now in Early Access on PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X|S.